Search the Community
Showing results for tags 'case history'.
Found 1 result
westcoast posted a topic in From journals and scientific sourcesCorrespondence Case reports M. D. Enoch The British Journal of Psychiatry Jan 2005, 186 (2) 169; DOI: 10.1192/bjp.186.2.169 Dr Williams courageously urges the Editor to think again regarding his predecessor's joy at hastening the demise of the case report . [That's Wilkinson, 2003, which like Williams 2004 is free, full text, and short.] Medicine generally is being dehumanised; if psychiatry follows suit, then we cannot complain that the masses are deserting us for alternative medicine. The bias of the Journal towards so-called ‘pure science’ while discarding the whole-person approach will accelerate the dehumanising process. Following the massive development of drug therapy from the mid-1950s there was a golden era when the so-called controlled experiments supported what we clinicians found in practice - that people improved with antidepressants and anxiolytics. For the past 40 years or so the Journal has been full of further ‘ research’ papers which have added little of note to our psychiatric knowledge. At the same time much fruitful research has occurred in the clinical field through the analysis of narrative and transference and the study of case reports. Uncommon Psychiatric Syndromes (Enoch & Ball, 2001), described by Littlewood (2004) as a pioneering book, now in its fourth edition and translated into several languages, arose from one case report, albeit followed by a further 35 years' (continuing) research. The pioneer Dr Rolf Strom Olsen, Superintendent of Runwell Hospital, encouraged every clinician to be a researcher; to think and to contribute to the advancement of our subject. Following one ward round he informed a young senior registrar that the case report that he had just presented was an example of the rare ‘delusion of doubles’ and insisted that the world literature be scanned for other examples. Little did we think at that time that the Capgras syndrome would become such a prominent condition throughout clinical psychiatry during the next 40 years. The same can be said for de Clérambault syndrome, now the explanation for about 50% of stalkers (the fashion disorder of the age), and folie à deux, which explains much of the mass phenomena of the past half century. Peter Hobson psychiatrist, experimental psychologist and psychoanalyst, protests effectively that successive editors rejected his papers on dynamic psychopathology as not being scientific enough. Hobson illustrates ‘how easy it is for the science to squeeze out the subjective, personal dimension of life in the quest for objectivity...’ (Hobson, 2002). The case history reminds us that the person is not merely a statistic but comprises body, mind and soul and that each must be taken into consideration for complete healing to occur. © 2005 Royal College of Psychiatrists References ↵ Enoch, D. & Ball, H. (2001) Uncommon Psychiatric Syndromes. London: Arnold. ↵ Hobson, P. (2002) The Cradle of Thought. London: Macmillan. ↵ Littlewood, R. (2004) Book review. Unusual Psychiatric Syndromes. Psychiatry, 3, 1-2. ↵ Williams, D. D. R. (2004) In defence of the case report (letter). British Journal of Psychiatry, 184, 84. FREE Full Text